Tuesday, October 02, 2007

NL Gold Gloves: Shortstop

Here are the NL Gold Glove candidates at shortstop. I'll evaluate them using Fielding Win Shares and Fielding Wins Above Average (derived from fielder runs above average on BP, divided by 9):


Shortstop FWS FWAA

Tulowitzki 10.9 2.6
Furcal 7.5 1.8
Ja.Wilson 7.2 2.1
Vizquel 6.8 0.3
Reyes 6.3 0.6
Hardy 6.2 0.7


You won't find two stronger arms than the top 2 guys on this list, although #5 on the list can get a lot on the ball too. Kudos to Vizquel for even appearing on the candidates list at his age.

Unlike David Wright, Reyes' defense did cost the Mets in the stretch drive. He lost half of his FWAA in the last 9 days.

It would be wrong, but don't be surprised if Vizquel wins this as a sentimental (and perennial) favorite.

My gold glove goes to Troy Tulowitzki in a landslide, which became even more landslidier in the last 10 days. The guy isn't getting enough respect. How did Holliday get player of the game in the final against the Pads when Troy hit a single, two doubles and a triple? Hell, Holliday didn't even touch the plate! Plus, Holliday misplayed a ball in the outfield.

Iron glove goes to David Eckstein. His weak arm is beginning to cost the Cards.