| PHoM Quota Method | ||
| # | Electee | Pos |
| 1. | Ross Barnes | 2b |
| 2. | Paul Hines | cf |
| 3. | George Wright | ss |
| 4. | Deacon White | 3b |
| PHoM Open Method | ||
| # | Electee | Pos |
| 1. | Ross Barnes | 2b |
| 2. | Paul Hines | cf |
| 3. | George Wright | ss |
| 4. | Deacon White | 3b |
| 5. | Al Spalding | sp |
| 6. | Ezra Sutton | 3b |
| 7. | George Gore | cf |
| 8. | Hardy Richardson | 2b/of |
| 9. | Charley Radbourn | sp |
| 10. | Charley Jones | rf |
| 11. | Lip Pike | cf |
| 12. | Cal McVey | c/1b |
